Articles / 4 min read
How to avoid coal scams in Pakistan: checks that save you money
To avoid coal scams in Pakistan, check the supplier before you pay, the weight at both ends of the road, and the coal on the day it is tipped. Each step below catches a different trick, in the order a truck moves.

Before you pay: is the supplier real?
The costliest scam is the supplier who does not exist: a Facebook or WhatsApp number offering coal far under the market, asking full payment in advance to book the truck, then going silent. A price well below the weekly sheet is the warning. Ask where the margin is coming from.
Ask for the business name, the depot address where the truck loads, and a second contact. A real merchant will tell you where the yard is and will not mind someone you know going to look. Ask for an NTN and check it against the FBR's active taxpayer list. Then phone another buyer who has taken trucks from the same supplier. One call to a fellow kiln or boiler owner tells you more than a website does.
A seller who can say only 'best coal, A-grade' and cannot give the field, the size in mm and the moisture to expect has told you he does not know the coal, or does not want to say.
Agreeing terms so that neither side holds all the risk
Avoid paying 100% before loading on a first order. A common middle path is part payment to book, then the balance against the weighbridge slip and the bilty showing the truck has left with your coal, or on arrival once you have checked the load. Write it down, even if only as a WhatsApp message. Pay into a business account in the supplier's name, never a stranger's personal account, and keep every receipt. After a few trucks of history, terms can relax.

At loading: the slip and the bilty
Ask for the loading weighbridge slip, showing truck number, gross, tare and net, on WhatsApp the moment the truck is loaded. Ask for a photo of the bilty the same day. The bilty is the goods company's receipt: its number, date, truck number, driver, sender, receiver, weight and freight.
Match the truck number on the slip, the bilty and the truck at your gate. A slip from a different truck is an old trick. If the bilty shows less weight than your invoice, or a different consignee, stop and ask before you pay the balance.
At your site: weigh again
Weigh the truck at a weighbridge near you before it unloads. Surface water dries on a 2 to 3 day road, so a small loss is normal, but a gap of more than a few hundred kilograms on 25 tonnes needs an answer. Weigh the empty truck after tipping if you can, so gross minus tare gives what you actually received. Photograph the load and the slips that day.
The sums justify the detour. Every tonne missing from a Duki lump truck is about Rs 51,750 at the delivered price on our sheet.
- 1 tonne short51,750 Rs lost
- 5% stone and shale (1.25 t)64,690 Rs lost
- 3 points more water than agreed (0.75 t)38,810 Rs lost
- 22 t delivered, 25 t billed155,250 Rs lost
- Billed 26 t, carries 22207,000 Rs lost
Value = tonnes x the delivered Duki lump price on our sheet. Stone and extra water also cost heat, so the real loss is a little higher.
On the heap: stone, water and swapped grades
Have someone at the gate who knows the order: grade, size, invoice weight and truck number. Do not let the driver tip until they match. Once the coal is on the ground and mixed with old stock you cannot prove anything.
Watch the first tipped load. Stones and grey shale are hard, dull, heavy pieces that do not break like coal; a few are normal in run-of-mine and a heap of them is not. Wet coal looks dark and shiny all through, leaves water in the truck bed and cakes in the fines. A cheaper grade sold under a dearer name, say Mach coal as Duki lump, shows in the size and the colour, so compare both with the analysis for this lot. An analysis with no lab name, date or sample reference proves nothing.
Take shovels from several places, mix them, and fill two bags. Seal both, write the date and truck number, keep one and send the other to a lab if the coal burns badly.
- Truck number matches on slip, bilty and truck.
- Net weight on the loading slip equals the invoice weight.
- Re-weighed near your site, slip kept.
- First load checked for stone, shale, mud and water.
- Two sealed sample bags, dated, with the truck number.
- Size and colour compared with the grade ordered.
If you think you have been cheated
Stop unloading if you safely can, phone the supplier and send photos of the load, the loading slip and your own weighbridge slip, on the day. A complaint a week later, after the coal is burned, is hard to settle. Honest merchants talk; one who goes quiet has answered the question. Hold back the balance until the gap is settled in writing, and keep the sealed bags unopened for a lab, since a lab report on your own sample is the one piece of evidence you control.
Prices are indicative, per tonne, excluding sales tax, and change week to week. See today's sheet or ask us for a confirmed price.



