Articles / 3 min read
Charcoal vs coal: which one for a BBQ restaurant, a depot or a kiln
Charcoal vs coal looks like a small question until a kiln owner orders the wrong one. Both are called koyla in Urdu. Charcoal is wood cooked down to carbon and belongs on a grill; mineral coal is dug from the ground and belongs in a kiln, boiler or foundry.

What each one is
Charcoal comes from logs stacked in a kiln or pit and burnt slowly with little air, until water and gases cook out. It is light, black, brittle and dirties your hands.
Arab News, visiting charcoal kilns at Gharo in Sindh in 2019, was told that about 200 kg of wood gives 50 kg of charcoal. That is 4 kg of wood for every 1 kg.
Mineral coal is buried plant matter pressed for millions of years. Industry in Pakistan buys mostly Balochistan coal from Duki, Chamalang, Sor Range, Mach and Harnai, plus Sindh coal; Thar lignite goes mainly to power plants. It still carries ash and sulphur: on our sheet, 9 to 25% ash and 3 to 6% sulphur depending on grade.
Myth: charcoal is the stronger fuel
Weight for weight, good charcoal is hot. The FAO reference is 30.8 MJ a kg, which works out near 7,350 kcal. Our grades run from 5,000 kcal for fines to 6,500 for Sor Range. So charcoal does beat coal on heat per kg.
That is the only round it wins for industry. Coal burns far longer in the fire, and a tonne of Duki run-of-mine leaves about 200 kg of ash where charcoal leaves very little. Charcoal lights in 15 to 20 minutes and runs nearly smokeless; coal smokes and smells of sulphur while it catches.
- Charcoal (FAO reference)7,350 kcal/kg
- Sor Range6,500 kcal/kg
- Chamalang lump6,300 kcal/kg
- Duki lump6,000 kcal/kg
- Duki run-of-mine5,500 kcal/kg
- Coal fines5,000 kcal/kg
Charcoal: 30.8 MJ/kg divided by 4.184 MJ per 1,000 kcal is 7,362, rounded to 7,350. Coal figures are the typical values on our price sheet.

Myth: coal will do on a grill
Tikka, seekh kebab and anything sitting right over the fire should go on charcoal. Balochistan coal carries 3 to 6% sulphur and smokes while it lights, and the smell goes into the food. Tandoors are the middle case: start on charcoal or wood, add coal, and bake once the coals glow and the smoke has stopped. Our tandoor chain and depot guide has the numbers for that.
Why a kiln or boiler should never buy charcoal
Scale is the problem. A 10 t/h textile boiler burns about 29 tonnes of Duki lump a day (the working is in our textile boiler guide). The same heat from charcoal at 7,350 kcal is about 24 tonnes a day, and at 4 kg of wood per kg of charcoal that is roughly 95 tonnes of wood a day, every day of the season.
Charcoal is made in small batches and sold by the kg at tals and grocery shops. There is no truck-load market with a lab certificate for ash and size, which a boiler maker or a kiln needs. Bhatta firing and boiler grates are built around coal's ash and size. Use coal: Duki run-of-mine and fines for kilns, Chamalang or Sor Range for boilers.
Notes for BBQ restaurants and depot traders
A restaurant buying charcoal pays by weight, so dust is money. A depot that stocks both keeps them in separate dry piles and sells them by the maund to different customers. Freshly made charcoal can heat up in a sack, so do not bag it hot.
Both fuels make carbon monoxide without enough air, and charcoal gives no smoke to warn you. Neither belongs in a closed room; see our carbon monoxide guide for workplaces.
- Charcoal should be dry, hard and ring slightly when two pieces knock together
- Avoid sacks full of crumbs and dust
- Half-burnt wood pieces that still show grain will smoke and spit
- Weigh on a scale; a sack called one maund is not a weight
- Never light either with petrol or spirit
Prices are indicative, per tonne, excluding sales tax, and change week to week. See today's sheet or ask us for a confirmed price.


